The relationship between chief financial officers and independent directors must evolve beyond regulatory oversight and compliance into a strategic partnership that improves business decisions and creates long-term shareholder value, finance leaders said at the inaugural ETCFO Annual Conclave 2026.
Speaking during a trialogue titled The Strategic Synergy Between CFOs and Independent Directors, Giridhar Sanjeevi, Board Chair and Independent Director and former CFO of IHCL; Sugata Sircar, Advisor, Independent Director and former CFO of Schneider Electric India; and Kedar Upadhye, CFO of Biocon, discussed how independent directors can help finance leaders navigate complex business decisions. The session was moderated by Vinit Jindal, Executive Director and CFO, Bayer CropScience.
The panellists argued that independent directors should not be viewed merely as compliance monitors. Their experience and external perspectives can help CFOs challenge management assumptions, improve capital allocation and strengthen enterprise value creation.
Governance must extend beyond compliance
Sanjeevi said governance is the foundation of boardroom engagement, but independent directors must look beyond regulatory responsibilities to contribute to business performance.
Drawing on his experience across boards and committees, he cited his involvement with a company transitioning from an unlisted to a listed entity. His contribution extended beyond ensuring compliance with listing requirements to examining its business model, identifying appropriate performance indicators and determining how the company should position itself before investors.
He also highlighted the importance of capital structure planning, including the geographical diversification of shareholders and participation by different categories of institutional investors. Independent directors with relevant experience and investor relationships can help companies understand market expectations and improve shareholder communication.
“Governance is the base on which everything else operates,” he said.
CFOs must participate in shaping strategy
Sircar said independent directors are increasingly expected to contribute to decisions involving mergers and acquisitions, technology investments, market entry and business transformation.
He also highlighted the changing expectations of CFOs, who must move beyond evaluating proposals developed by other functions to actively shaping strategic decisions.
He illustrated this through an industrial company considering an expansion of its sourcing network. While its existing sourcing arrangements offered cost efficiencies, geopolitical uncertainties created a case for establishing an additional sourcing base in another country. This could increase immediate costs but improve supply chain resilience.
A strategically engaged CFO should identify such risks and help develop the proposal rather than assess it solely on conventional financial returns. Independent directors can bring external perspectives to help management evaluate the trade-off between short-term profitability and long-term resilience.
Constructive challenges can improve capital allocation
Upadhye said independent directors bring experience that is often underutilised when their role is restricted to governance and compliance.
While executive management has a deeper understanding of its industry and competitors, familiarity can sometimes create fixed assumptions about business performance and operational constraints. Independent directors with cross-industry experience can challenge these assumptions and encourage alternative approaches.
He recalled an instance in which an independent director questioned his assumptions about working capital requirements in a pharmaceutical business, prompting him to reassess the company’s practices against those in other industries.
Upadhye said CFOs should actively seek independent directors’ perspectives, including through discussions outside formal board meetings, while keeping the CEO and relevant management informed.
Transparency builds trust during uncertainty
The panellists emphasised that CFOs must communicate difficult business developments before every aspect of a problem has been resolved.
Sanjeevi introduced the concept of “narrative optionality”, describing it as the ability of finance leaders to preserve credibility through consistent and transparent communication.
Drawing on his experience during the pandemic and the subsequent recovery of the hospitality industry, he said CFOs should communicate what management understands while acknowledging what remains uncertain.
Withholding difficult information until every question has been answered can weaken credibility. Early communication, on the other hand, allows independent directors to understand emerging risks and contribute to finding solutions.
Escalating difficult issues requires judgment
Upadhye said the timing of board-level communication should depend on the seriousness of the issue. Business uncertainties involving margins, growth visibility or strategic decisions should generally allow management time to analyse the problem and develop a response.
However, concerns involving integrity or potential violations of company law require greater urgency.
He stressed the importance of following appropriate escalation processes and maintaining transparency with senior management, cautioning against unnecessarily bypassing the CEO. The objective should be to protect the company’s interests while ensuring legitimate concerns receive appropriate attention.
Board relationships must allow constructive disagreement
A recurring theme was that trust between CFOs and independent directors should not mean an absence of disagreement.
Upadhye said differences of opinion are particularly valuable when companies evaluate acquisitions and capital allocation decisions, including whether to pursue a transaction, how much to pay or whether to delay it.
Such disagreements can improve decisions when supported by scenario analysis and open discussion. However, they become personal confrontations when the parties do not trust each other’s intentions.
Sircar also emphasised healthy debate, saying that engaging directors before formal meetings and explaining competing considerations can make disagreements more productive.
Reflecting on his transition from CFO to independent director, Sircar said board members need more than minimum reporting requirements to understand the businesses they oversee. CFOs should proactively share information on market developments, operational challenges, competitive pressures and emerging risks rather than limit engagement to scheduled board meetings.
Summarising the discussion, moderator Vinit Jindal highlighted three principles: independence does not require distance, trust does not eliminate challenge, and transparency should not depend on having every answer in advance.
The broader message was that effective board engagement must move beyond reviewing past performance towards shaping future business outcomes. CFOs need to participate proactively in strategic decisions, while independent directors must engage deeply with business models and management assumptions without compromising their oversight responsibilities.
Ultimately, combining financial expertise with independent perspectives and constructive challenge can help companies manage risks, allocate capital more effectively and create long-term shareholder value.
